Beitragvon boert » 31. Okt 2007 20:50
The cartoon deals with the topic of global warming. In the cartoon there is a parking lot with many different types of cars displayed. One of the cars,
, which is shown in the center of the cartoon, is much bigger than the others. All of the cars bear flags as their license plates, so each car represents a certain country.
The biggest car bears not only a flag but also the word “USA”. While all cars are very small and unsignificant this big one
seems the more hugest. It has blackened windows and gives off the most exhaust fumes. Also Additionally it is a special type of car, a typical American car called SUV, which means “Sports Ulility Vehicle”.
These types of cars consume a lot of gas and pollute the environment (, because of their high emission | Doppelt). In this way they contribute a lot to global warming. Nevertheless all the cars do not give off any exhaust fumes, they are parked and the motor is switched off - in contrast to the American SUV.
In the cartoon’s background there is also a building, a sign at its frontside explains that this is the conference venue of the international conference on global warming.
of these facts the cartoonist’s intention is clearly to see. (With this cartoon) he critisizes the USAs environmental politics relating to the global warming. The USA plays an important role because of its polluting attitude and is, like it is shown here, one of the biggest environmental polluters in the world. The USA is now and then the only state that is not ready to consent to the conservation provisions. This again shows the people ’s view of the importance of conservation.
So it is highly probable that American people do not care that much about
care of the environment. It seems like they are just interested in – to take up the idea of the SUV – status symbols, which show their wealth without wasting just one thought about the environment. Also the government disapproves of all conservation proposals. It seems that they want to show their power just by refusing all proposals which are not of their own.
After analyzing the cartoon, I would say that the cartoonist disapproves of the American environmental politics, which is clearly shown by the way he portrays the USA as the biggest polluter
at of all. In my opinion the United States contribute to the global warming in a high way, but are not to blame for this all alone.
The use of cartoons alongside articles has become more and more popular for School Accessed Courseworks (SACs) and end of year English exam. At first glance and even the second glance, cartoons may not always appear to contain great amounts of information for students to analyse. However, when students know what to look for, it can be a vital jump-start for an insightful cartoon analysis. After all, there is a reason why teachers and examiners choose to use cartoons. It is crucial that students develop a strong ability to analyse cartoons with or without written articles.
While there are many resources helping students gain skills in analysing written articles, few are specifically focused on cartoons. Below are 10 things you should look for in cartoons. These are common techniques used by illustrators and are a fantastic starting point in cartoon analysis.
In coloured cartoons, there are myriad of things you can look for. Ask yourself these questions:
- What colours did the illustrator use?
- What colours are used most? Least?
- Is there a repetition of colours?
- Is there only one colour?
Colours can be separated into two groups – warm colours and cool colours. Warm colours including red, orange and yellow may be used to evoke feelings of comfort and warmth. It can also be used to express anger and embarrassment. Meanwhile, cool colours including blue, green and purple may represent calm and tranquility. Otherwise it can mean sadness and misery (download our full guide on cartoon analysis below which includes finer details about colour meanings).
Remember that a group of colours can represent an overall meaning:
- Red, blue and white – can represent Australian flag and symbolises patriotism.
- Red, orange, and dark brown – can represent earth and nature.
While analysing colourful cartoons, also consider that many cartoons are black and white. Although these cartoons lack colour, illustrators use other methods to create meaning.
- What shading is used? – heavy shading can mean power and solidity; light shading can indicate frailty and insignificance.
- What textures/patterns are used? – smooth or rough.
- What shapes are there?
Remember that no cartoons are simply just ‘black and white.’
Analysis: The monochromatic national broadband laid across mountains and kilometers just to serve one shack may represent a sombre plan that is pointless for Australian citizens.
Size is an important element in cartoons and one that is often quite obvious. Investigate:
- Is anything disproportioned?
- Exaggerated? Under-exaggerated?
- What is large and what is small?
Analysis: The oversized ‘WikiLake’ appears to be irrepressible and too overwhelming for any of the three politicians from preventing another information release.
Background: Wikileaks exposes information about Hilary Clinton and Kevin Rudd and Julia Gillard’s subsequent condemnation of the website.
- What is labeled?
- What do the labels say?
- Do the labels tell us the situation? Person? Time change?
Background: In the aftermath of the 2011 Queensland floods, many will be seeking insurance for home and business damages.
Analysis: The label ‘Grin Insurance’ is satirical in that one would expect a customer to be ‘grinning’ to have their insurance. However, the insurance policy only ‘covers [them] against small ‘f’ flood’, not the ‘capital ‘F’ Flood’ they have just experienced, leaving them with no insurance and little to ‘grin’ about.
4. Speech bubbles
- Who is speaking?
- What are they saying?
- Is it a conversation?
Background: Cows contribute to greenhouse gases via flatuence of methane gas.
Analysis: The irony of a cow stating that he is a ‘climate change septic’ when his own release of methane gas is a significant cause in growing greenhouse gases.
A symbol is something that represents or stands for something else, usually an idea. They are commonly found throughout daily lives such as the cross for Christinity or the Red Cross for the organisation that helps victims of war or natural disasters. Sometimes symbols may be as obvious as those mentioned above, yet other times may be more subtle in their meaning.
- What symbols are incorporated?
- Why are particular symbols used?
- Is it a well-known symbol?
- Is the symbol’s meaning clear and identifiable? Or is it vague and can have multiple interpretations?
Background: Ted Baillieu, opposition leader against John Brumby in 2010 Victorian state elections.
Analysis: The representation of Baillieu as an iceberg indicates that he is a powerful force preventing the Labor Party from moving forwards and winning the 2010 state elections. The cartoon symbolises the famous movie, Titanic, and indicates that the Labor Party is bound to ‘sink’ against Baillieu and fail to ‘move forward’ to a victory.
The focus of a cartoon can indicate the main issue or situation.
- What is in focus?
- What is in the foreground and background?
Background: Wikileaks obtaining information about politicians.
Analysis: While a gigantic fly labeled ‘Wikileaks’ is the main focus of the cartoon, it is humorous in that it succeeds in surreptitiously listening in on Kevin Rudd and Hilary Clinton’s unsuspecting private conversation.
Angles often provide readers an indication of the status of particular people or things. If the angle is sloping down, then it creates an image of a smaller person or item. This indicates weakness, inferiority and powerlessness. An angle sloping up towards a person or item provides it with power, superiority and authority. A straight-on angle can represent equality.
- Is the angle sloping up?
- Is the angle sloping down?
- Is it straight on?
- From behind? Front on?
- On top or below?
Background: Banks and Power Companies are two sectors important to Australian society.
Analysis: The angle tilted up towards the Bank and Power Company demonstrates that they are domineering, powerful and authoritative.
The tone of a cartoon can indicate the illustrator’s attitude and stance towards the issue.
Common cartoon tones VCE Study Guide’s 195 Tones Vocabulary.
Background: The North Koreans are well known for their possession of nuclear weapons.
Analysis: Although North Korea has made significant technological advances with their nuclear weapons, it is ironic that their other tools of war remain underdeveloped, perhaps since the Middle Ages as the catapult implies.
9. Facial Expression
Facial expressions are key to the character’s thoughts, feelings and emotions.
- What facial expressions are used?
- Do they change (sequential cartoons)?
- How do expressions compare to another’s expression?
- Is it an expression we expect?
Background: Prince William introducing Kate Middleton to his royal family.
Analysis: While Prince William appears to be proud and excited to introduce Kate to his family, his fiancé’s expression demonstrates that perhaps she may be apprehensive about the event.
The context of a cartoon is important. Most of the time, cartoons are attached to articles and usually draw upon a point contended by the writer of the article.
- Does the cartoon support or oppose the article?
- Is it relevant or irrelevant?
- Does it focus on the past, present or future?
- Which aspect of the article does it relate to?
- Does it add further information?
However, there are times when you will have to analyse a cartoon alone, where it is not accompanying an article. In this case you will have to understand the background, the situation and the issue that is represented.
Did you know that our VCE English Essentials Study Guide includes offers a even more comprehensive guide on Language Analysis? Click here to download a FREE sample chapter from the study guide!